- class=”idgTitles”>
- Macworld
- PC Advisor
- Tech Reviews
- Digital Arts
- class=”breadcrumbs” itemprop=”breadcrumb”>
- Home
- News
- Newswire
- 3G patent disputed by Apple, HTC and Nokia upheld by European Patent Office
The European Patent Office (EPO) has upheld a narrowed version of a patent on 3G technology at the heart of Several legal disputes in Germany, an EPO spokesman said Thursday.
The European Patent Office (EPO) has upheld a narrowed version of a patent on 3G technology at the heart of Several legal disputes in Germany, an EPO spokesman said Thursday.
By upholding the patent, Which its owner IPCom has’ declared essential to 3G standards, the EPO rejected claims from Nokia, HTC, Apple, Ericsson and Vodafone, Which opposed the patent, the spokesman said.
The EPO had Previously denied a Broader version of the patent, but on Wednesday upheld IPCom’s narrower redrafting of it, According To the EPO spokesman. The decision can be appealed, but it is not yet clear Whether thatwill happen, he said.
The Patent Describes the allocation of network access via the so-called Random Access Channel (RACH), allo wing handsets access to the networks of the various mobile telecommunications providers, IPCom said, in a news release. “As such, it is standard-essential within the UMTS and LTE standards, and its use is mandatory,” it said.
standard essential patents (SEPs) are patents That the owner deems essential to the implementation of Industry Standards. Companies That declare Their patents as standards-essential, are USUALLY required to license them on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory (FRAND) terms. Would-be licensees, however, thwart disagree about what constitutes a reasonable licensing fee.
The technology described in the IPCom patents, originally developed by Bosch, ice Particularly important for the emergency services and police, since it can give them priority access to networks in emergencies, even if the networks are overloaded, According To IPCom.IPCom said smartphones made by Nokia, HTC and others documents currently deviate from the UMTS 3G standard In Their use of the Random Access Channel, Claiming They did this to avoid paying license fees. However, they are still solving the same problem using a slightly different technology, and That is not enough to avoid infringing the patent, said an IPCom spokesman.
Nokia spokesman Mark Durrant saidthat the version of IPCom’s patent upheld by the EPO was so Substantially narrowed That it willhave no effect on Nokia.“Nokia does not believe That it is possible for any UMTS product to infringe the narrowed form of the patent. Yet again, IPCom Appears to be overestimating the value of its Remaining patents, “he said via email.
But IPCom overpriced accused the handset vendors of putting public safety at risk In Their Attempts to avoid Patent Infringement. If the vendors were to deviate from the standard father enough to cases outside the scope of IPCom’s patents, They would overpriced cases outside of the UMTS standard, whichcould interfering with the correct Functioning of the network and lead to a security risk in an emergency, the spokesman said.
Nokia’s Durrant shot back: “Claims That we are somehow interfering with correct operation of the networks or risking security are just not right.” He saidthat the feature described in the narrowed patent, Which covers Prioritizing access to the network in special situations, is an optional one in the standard – and One That no operator has Implemented in its UMTS 3G networks. Even if a network had Implemented the feature, Nokia’s devices would still the comply to the UMTS standard, he said.
HTC fired time immediately respond to a request for comment.
Now that the EPO has upheld the patent, a number of court cases on damages and Infringement are slated to take place in the coming months, IPCom said. Among them are a damages case against Apple That is scheduled for February 11 at the Regional Court of Mannheim and an Infringement Case Against Nokia scheduled for May 28 at the Higher Regional Court of Karlsruhe, it said.Apple fired time immediately respond to a request for comment.
IPCom wants the companies to license the patents. “The industry Should bear in mind That damages for patent Infringement set by the courts Can Be Significantly higher than a license at FRAND conditions,” it said.
Founded in 2007, IPCom is a patent license manager with a portfolio of almost 1,200 patents in about 160 patent families in the field of mobile communications, According To its website. It claims 35 of Those families are essential to implementation of key mobile communications standards in 2G (GSM), 2.5G (GPRS), 3G (UMTS) and Subsequent generation.
Loek is Amsterdam Correspondent and covers online privacy, intellectual property, open source and online payment issues for the IDG News Service. Follow him on Twitter at @ loekessers or email advice and comments to loek_essers@idg.com Share this article
Article Comments
Read More
- class=”relList”>
- Nokia files another ITC complaint against Apple in the U.S.
- Important Samsung mobile patents likely to be invalid, German court says
- Motorola fails to make patent case against Apple in German court
Market Place
Everything Tablet brings you the latest casing and accessories helping you to person alise, protect and get the most out of your tablet. Working at the intersection of fashion and function we create products for trend-setters and tech-heads alike!.
Zip Cloud or cancel backs up your Files, Folders and all your Important Documents. Nominated for MacWorldUK Best Professional Software, coupled with Award winning iPhone and iPad apps, Zip Cloud really is the number 1 choice in Cloud Storage Today. Try Unlimited Cloud Storage Today for FREE!.
TemplateCloud.com is the design marketplace for graphic designers. You create designs, and use our software to build theminto online editable templates. We sell your designs in different countries with different websites. Each time a customer uses your design, we pay you a royalty; the price is set by you.
Amsys ice Azimut as the technical leader in Apple and has underdeveloped bespoke technical products and solutions to deliver class leading support to its business clients. Amsys clients can select from consultancy, integration, break-fix, recruitment, training and app development. Amsys make Apple products work for business.
NAD Electronics has always stood out by doing things differently. Our relentless pursuit of great sound has earned us a ‘giant killer’ reputation. Every product is designed with heart and soul you can hear, Emphasizing quality over quantity. We focus on the inside where it counts-and where you can hear the results.
It’s the world’s first robotic ball That You control from your smartphone or tablet. You can drive Sphero, play tabletop and multiplayer games, use Sphero as a handheld controller for on-screen gameplay, and even explore augmented reality. Now with 20 + apps:
MeteoGroup WeatherPro – the award winning weather app! Developed by professional meteorologists and Providing weather forecasts for over 2 million locations with real-time, high resolution radar and satellite images, ski weather, water tempera tures and more, WeatherPro is the most accurate and comprehensive weather app on the market.
Hardsoft are the only ‘one stop’ solution for the supply and finance of IT to Businesses throughout the UK by our regional branch offices. We are uniquely both equipment Apple Approved Reseller and licensed Credit Brokers and have a Tailored solutionwhich includes a full 3 year warranty and an equipment upgrade every 18 months.
How to file UK tax return online: stress-free self-assessment made easy
Why your home is about to get a lot smarter: Automate your house without spending thou sands
Corel Painter Kills Freestyle app thatoffers Kinect-style painting using the Leap Motion
iWork for iCloud apps get password protection, other improvements
No comments:
Post a Comment